The next day began with a tour of Lola’s property. There are about 9 hectares in all, with about 6 of it currently used for agriculture. The largest portion of the land is dedicated to rice fields. There are trees planted in another section – hemolina and mahogany. Still another is planted with vegetables – several varieties of eggplant, beans, peas, tomatoes, etc. The resthouse occupies another segment. The last…well that section is home to over 100 squatters who have put up homes on the property by families who do not own – or in most cases even rent – the land. Our trip to Santiago gave us our first real glimpse into the tensions and the joys of landowners, and those struggling to join the rank of landowner. Jordan has written a thoughtful “memoir” on one of his experiences in Santiago, which includes his reflections on the children from the families of squatters. He worked very hard on that post and its worth a read to get a nine-year old’s perspective. I’ll try and share a bit of mine here
Our days included taking care of tasks on the house and land as needed, getting Lola to and from meetings with local government officials, and sharing stories about the property, its history, and its significance. The land has been in Lola’s family for a long, long time. Her father’s family is from the province and owned a lot of land there in the past. Her mother struggled during wartime to hold on to the land and Lola has held on to it since, trying to make the most of it despite living half a world away. The emotional and sentimental significance to the land is palpable in Lola’s words when she shares her stories from the porch of this resthouse that sits on the small parcel of land that represents one of the last vestiges of Mamauog family in the region. In her own words she says that every time she comes back to Isabela she resolves to sell it, but when she actually arrives, she is unable to let it go. From a practical standpoint there is no reason to keep it, but it is abundantly clear that this farm isn’t just a matter of practicality.
The squatters I mentioned early actually play a central role in all this. One parcel of land has been essentially taken over by their homes. Rather than battle to displace these families, Lola worked tirelessly through negotiations with the squatters and the government to allow them to buy the land. Though she sold it through a government program at far less than the market value, she helped countless families become landowners. As you walk the streets that now line this portion of the land, if Lola is with you it feels a bit like you are walking alongside the Godfather. Everyone bows or nods in respect to this little Filipina as she passes by their houses. At first glance she looks like an average, elderly woman, but when they realize it is “Manang Landel”, they quickly change their stance and reverent greetings pour out.
Their regard for Lola was further demonstrated by a party they held for her. Jordan wrote about it is his blog, but in short, the squatters shared the expense for hosting a meal, complete with fresh lechon roasted right in Lola’s yard and the biggest bowls of pancit and rice I have ever seen. I suspect 60 people showed up to join the feast and pay their respects. Their willingness to go to such expense their way of expressing their gratitude for what Lola has done for them and their families. For many, their ability to own a bit of land themselves is clearly life-changing.
But, what about the other parcels? Squatters are starting to settle in there as well, encroaching on the farmland. Some appear “needy”; others simply appear “greedy”. One solution is to continue to sell the land to them as with the other parcel and simply let it all go. Though this may provide housing and land for those in need, it surrenders a long family history to strangers. Farmland is being eaten up in the region by housing and commercial development. Should that be the fate of Lola’s land too in a country that currently is unable to produce enough rice to feed its own people? Lola has hopes and aspirations for the property to allow it to be productive and serve the region for years to come, but to act on them means to battle the squatters and require them to move. Once they are there, getting them to move is not trivial – they have “rights” as squatters under human rights legislation that seem to supersede Lola’s property rights as the landowner. The legal process is long and cumbersome. Finding a solution is not trivial.
Part of our time in Santiago was spent searching for that solution. We visited Isabela State University in Cabagan to talk with a group there involved in development and conservation. We met with another group in Ilagan working to help farmers implement sustainable agrifarming practices and use organic farming methods. These meetings began to spark Lola’s imagination. Perhaps these groups could partner with her and help her develop the land. Perhaps their involvement could provide more oversight of the land which would deter more squatters from settling. Perhaps the land could become a pilot farm? a demonstration site? a training facility? Maybe a school – an idea Lola has had for some time – could be co-located and work in cooperation with the farm? Are these visions more valuable that providing homes to squatters? How to you place a value on these different ideas and come to a “good” decision.
We surfaced many ideas during those five days. Nothing is decided and nothing is yet done. The land continues to be used by the squatters – and what will come of them remains unresolved. Lola will return to the states in December and what will happen to the land between now and her next visit is anyone’s guess. Lola is now in her 80’s. What will she be able to complete and enact during her lifetime? What can we do as her direct family to support her hopes and aspirations when we are so far away? Will we be able to see it through? If not us, then who?
As with any complex problem, in your search for answers it seems you simply get more questions. The questions about the property are simply the tip of the iceberg – there are many, many more. I left asking myself some tough personal questions that were not easy to ask, nor answer. Hans and I have been married for 15 years. Why has it taken us this long to visit these places that are clearly so important to Lola – did we not recognize their importance earlier? Have they just become more important because Lola is getting older or were we just too consumed with our own busy and full lives not to fully see it? What can we do to help Lola? Are we willing to do it? What changes does that mean for us? What about the rest of the family – how can we work together to help?
In our short four months here we have developed a real fondness for this place and a strong connection with the many family and friends we have here. It is our hope that it will not be 15 years before we return again. And, it is our hope that we will be willing to continue to think about all these challenging questions in an effort to find solutions. We are grateful that Lola and Grandpa have shared all their stories with us in a setting where their significance is so visible. We are also thankful that they were patient enough to wait 15 years for us to be ready to listen. Our ears – and hearts – our open and ready to hear more.